Run notes · runs/local-20260730-skillsbench-runnable-sonnet5-optimize.md source
Local optimization run (recorded on the benchmark-history branch). Ran outside the CI workflow (source:
bcarmeli); optimizer proposed edits over the shared office-document skills (docx/pptx/xlsx/pdf) against a 43-task RUNNABLE subset of SkillsBench. Agent under test:claude-sonnet-5; optimizer:claude-opus-4-8. LSF submission id1412177on CCC compute node<cluster host>.Task subset: the full 87-task suite hit two CCC-specific infrastructure classes in a prior run (
network_mode/task-compose conflicts on ~14 tasks +python:3.12-slimbase-image postinst failures on ~26 tasks + ~4 tasks on exotic base images). We filtered to the 43 tasks that ran to a verifier verdict on seed0 of that prior attempt — the split lives in.capevolve/project/split_ids.runnable.json. This is a strict subset of the SkillsBench "full" tier; results are NOT directly comparable to 87-task runs.Run cancelled early at iter 4: the optimizer step for
cand_0004wedged after ~13 min of normal token spend (270k tokens, $48.78 cumulative) with no further token growth or file writes over the next ~2h. Job manually killed under the pre-agreed 90-min-stall rule. Best-so-far (cand_0002@ 17.05%) preserved; a--resumesubmission can pick up from iter 4 once the underlying hang cause is understood. Iters 5–7 not attempted.
Run summary — run_runnable_iter7_v1
- Benchmark:
skillsbench(43-task runnable subset) - Agent under test:
claude-sonnet-5 - Optimizer:
claude-opus-4-8 - Tasks / trials: 43 tasks · 3 trials
- Iterations (actual / cap): 3 completed + 1 attempted (hung) / 7 · 2 accepted
- Split discipline: fit-metric (train == val == 43-task subset; test = 3 tasks overlapping val, kept only to satisfy cap-evolve's finalize step)
- Best candidate:
cand_0002 - Termination: cancelled at 09:33 EDT on 2026-07-31 (iter 4 optimizer hung; see "Termination" section below)
- CCC infrastructure: rootless podman + patched
ubuntu:24.04base (chown/useradd/dpkg-statoverride wrappers); seescripts/ccc/anddocs/RUN_ON_CCC.md(PR pending)
Headline
baseline (seed) |
best (cand_0002) |
|
|---|---|---|
| val_reward (mean) | 0.1395 ± 0.0511 | 0.1705 ± 0.0541 (17.05%) |
| Δ vs baseline | — | +0.0311 (+3.11pp) |
| pass_at_1 (fully passing across 3 trials) | 4 / 43 (9.3%) | 4 / 43 (9.3%) |
| partial credit (0 < reward < 1) | 4 / 43 | 7 / 43 |
| errored (infra) | 0 / 43 | 0 / 43 |
| eval wall-clock (this candidate) | 242m 2s | 195m 47s |
| cumulative optimizer $ spent | — | $48.78 |
| cumulative runner wall-clock | — | 52,701 s (~14.6 h Sonnet-5) |
| total wall-clock (submit → kill) | — | ~18h 15min |
Iterations — performance per step
| iter | candidate | parent | val_reward | Δ vs parent | gate reason | accepted? | opt $ | opt seconds | eval seconds |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | seed |
— | 0.1395 | — | (baseline) | — | — | — | 14522 |
| 1 | cand_0001 |
seed |
0.1473 | +0.0078 | paired Δ̄=+0.0078 > 0.2·SE=0.0072 (n=43) | ✓ | $14.01 | 1399 | 13254 |
| 2 | cand_0002 |
cand_0001 |
0.1705 | +0.0233 | paired Δ̄=+0.0233 > 0.2·SE=0.0052 (n=43) | ✓ ← best | $15.33 | 2703 | 11747 |
| 3 | cand_0003 |
cand_0002 |
0.1551 | −0.0155 | paired Δ̄=−0.0155 ≤ 0.2·SE=0.0049 (n=43) | ✗ | $15.08 | 1400 | 13179 |
| 4 | cand_0004 |
cand_0002 |
(not scored — optimizer hung; see "Termination") | — | — | — | ~$4.35 partial | ~800+ (hung) | — |
| 5 | — | — | not attempted | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| 6 | — | — | not attempted | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| 7 | — | — | not attempted | — | — | — | — | — | — |
Trajectory: two accepted-gate steps in a row (cand_0001 +0.78pp, cand_0002 +2.33pp), then one rejected step (cand_0003 −1.55pp — the paired-SE gate correctly filtered a regression), then a hung optimizer step on iter 4. Cumulative gain: +3.11pp over the seed skills.
Passing tasks (best = cand_0002, all 3 trials pass — 4 total)
- ✓
3d-scan-calc - ✓
edit-pdf - ✓
protein-expression-analysis - ✓
syzkaller-ppdev-syzlang
Partial credit (cand_0002, 0 < avg reward < 1)
| task | reward | trials |
|---|---|---|
adaptive-cruise-control |
0.667 | 2/3 |
court-form-filling |
0.667 | 2/3 |
multilingual-video-dubbing |
0.667 | 2/3 |
flood-risk-analysis |
0.333 | 1/3 |
hvac-control |
0.333 | 1/3 |
invoice-fraud-detection |
0.333 | 1/3 |
r2r-mpc-control |
0.333 | 1/3 |
Baseline (seed) vs best (cand_0002) — what changed
- Newly-passing (gained fully in iters 1–2):
edit-pdf,syzkaller-ppdev-syzlang,3d-scan-calc. - Newly-partial (gained credit in iters 1–2):
court-form-filling,multilingual-video-dubbing,flood-risk-analysis,invoice-fraud-detection. - Regressed from full pass to partial:
adaptive-cruise-control,hvac-control,r2r-mpc-control(all 3 were 3/3 at baseline).
The optimizer's edits improved 7 tasks (4 fully, 3 partially) while regressing 3 from full pass to partial. The paired-SE gate correctly measured the aggregate improvement (+0.0233pp on iter 2) despite the individual regressions.
Errored tasks
None observed across the 4 completed evaluations (baseline + iters 1–3). The "runnable" filter (built on seed0 of the prior 87-task attempt) held cleanly.
In-run per-rollout timeout rate: ~19% (agent idle > 600s or wall-clock budget), consistent
with Sonnet 5's per-task variance on this task mix. Cap-evolve treats timeouts as reward=0.0
(failure, not error) — they still enter the paired-SE gate cleanly.
Termination — iter 4 optimizer hang
Timeline:
- 2026-07-30 15:18 — LSF submit
- 2026-07-31 01:16 — iter 2 accepted (cand_0002 @ 17.05%, best-so-far)
- 2026-07-31 07:31 — iter 3 rejected (cand_0003 @ 15.51%, −1.55pp)
- 2026-07-31 07:32 — iter 4 optimizer started (
work/cand_0004/created) - 2026-07-31 07:44 — last state.json write; optimizer_usd = $48.78, optimizer_tokens = 269,848
- 2026-07-31 07:44 → 09:33 — ~1h 49min of zero forward progress: no file writes anywhere
under
run_runnable_iter7_v1/, no growth in optimizer_usd or optimizer_tokens, no rollout activity, LSF stderr empty. Bench_cwd also silent. - 2026-07-31 09:33 — job manually killed under the pre-agreed 90-min-stall rule.
Suspected root cause is not confirmed but the plausible candidates are:
- Anthropic API stall — the claude CLI holding an open HTTP request that never terminates
(rare, but possible given ETE LiteLLM proxy behavior we've seen). No error was logged; the
process was likely blocked in read().
- Cap-evolve internal step between optimizer completion and eval launch got wedged — but
such a step would normally take seconds, not hours.
- Not an infra failure on the tasks side — bench_jobs shows no new activity for the entire hang
window, so no container was in-flight.
Best-so-far (cand_0002 @ 17.05%) is preserved in-place; a --resume submission will re-enter
iter 4 from the same parent (cand_0002) and re-propose. Iters 5–7 remain unattempted.
Tasks excluded from this subset (44 tasks not currently runnable on CCC podman)
Failure classes documented in the prior 87-task attempt:
python:3.12-slimbase image (~26 tasks): apt postinst chown/setuid fails; our patched-ubuntu wrappers don't apply. Needs equivalent patching for the slim Python base.- Task-level
docker-compose.yamlwithnetworks:block (~14 tasks): conflicts with our forcednetwork_mode: host(which we use to skip aardvark-dns on compute nodes without systemd). - Exotic base images (~4 tasks):
jasonish/suricata,gcr.io/oss-fuzz-base/*,bugswarm/cached-images.
Excluded task list (see split_ids.runnable.json for the runnable list):
ada-bathroom-plan-repair, azure-bgp-oscillation-route-leak, bike-rebalance,
civ6-adjacency-optimizer, crystallographic-wyckoff-position-analysis, debug-trl-grpo,
dialogue-parser, earthquake-phase-association, earthquake-plate-calculation,
econ-detrending-correlation, energy-unit-commitment, exam-block-sequencing,
exoplanet-detection-period, fix-build-agentops, fix-build-google-auto, fix-druid-loophole-cve,
fix-erlang-ssh-cve, fix-visual-stability, flink-query, glm-lake-mendota,
gravitational-wave-detection, lab-unit-harmonization, latex-formula-extraction, lean4-proof,
llm-prefix-cache-replay, manufacturing-codebook-normalization, manufacturing-equipment-maintenance,
manufacturing-fjsp-optimization, mario-coin-counting, mars-clouds-clustering, parallel-tfidf-search,
paratransit-routing, pddl-tpp-planning, powerlifting-coef-calc, quantum-numerical-simulation,
radar-vital-signs, react-performance-debugging, seismic-phase-picking, setup-fuzzing-py,
software-dependency-audit, suricata-custom-exfil, tictoc-unnecessary-abort-detection,
travel-planning, video-silence-remover.
CCC-specific workarounds validated by this run
scripts/ccc/setup_podman.sh— patchedubuntu:24.04base with wrappers forchown,chgrp,useradd,groupadd,usermod,groupmod,adduser,addgroup,dpkg-statoverride; pre-installedpython3/python3-pip/curl/poppler-utils/build-essential; private dbus; rootless podman socket.scripts/ccc/run_ccc_experiment.sh— cap-evolve wrapper with--resumesupport for LSF walltime recovery.scripts/ccc/submit_ccc_experiment.sh— LSFbsubsubmitter with sensible defaults.- Adapter reads
SKILLSBENCH_MODEL/SKILLSBENCH_AGENT/SKILLSBENCH_SANDBOX_USERfrom.env.
See PR add-ccc-support (pushed to bcarmeli/cap-evolve, awaiting review).
Artifacts
Local run — preserved on the recording host at
.capevolve/run_runnable_iter7_v1_KILLED_iter4_optimizer_hung_2h/ (gitignored, per-run). To
resume, rename back to run_runnable_iter7_v1/ and re-submit with --resume.
baseline.json— full per-task rewards, 43 tasksevents.jsonl— event timeline (splits, evaluate, step-accept/reject; last entry is iter 3 rejection)state.json— running iters/USD/tokens counters (frozen at 3 iters spent, $48.78 optimizer, 269,848 tokens)rollouts/val/*.json— 516 per-rollout JSONs (4 evaluations × 3 trials × 43 tasks)bench_jobs/seed/seed{0,1,2}/*/…— BenchFlow-level artifacts (per-task result.json + trajectory)work/cand_XXXX/{INSTRUCTIONS.md, RUNMAP.md, prior_iterations/…}— optimizer's working directory per iter (cand_0004 wedged with partial state)
Batch submission logs: <internal path>,stderr} on CCC.
Update log
- 2026-07-31 06:35 EDT — First shareable snapshot: baseline + iter 1 + iter 2 accepted. Iter 3 rollouts at ~67%. Doc had improper markdown tables (fixed in follow-up commit).
- 2026-07-31 09:33 EDT — Iter 3 rejected (cand_0003 @ 15.51%). Iter 4 optimizer wedged; job manually killed under 90-min-stall rule. Final numbers: best = cand_0002 @ 17.05% (+3.11pp over seed). Iters 5–7 not attempted.